Salafi Research Institute SRI
Translated & Annotated
Abu Khuzaimah Ansari
The 3rd – Report of
Ubaydullah bin al-Hasan Rahimahullah
KEY BLACK BOLD = Shaykh Abdul Qadir al-Junayd.
Blue [AK…..END] my annotations
Harb al-Kirmani transmit in his Masailuhu (2/286)
[AK] This a typographical error, 286 should be 886. It is in his Masail (2/286 no.1416) as, from al-Akhdar from Arim from [Wuhayb bin] Khalid who said, “I heard Ubaydullah say concerning the backbiting of the Khawarij and ruler which was done publicly, that he did not consider it backbiting. As for person who knows he is sinning, it is incumbent upon him to conceal it. He saw this as backbiting from them.” END]
His Shaykh who is in the chain Abu Abdur Rahman al-Akdhar bin Manjab, his biography cannot be found.
[AK] Dr. Fayiz, who published his Doctoral Thesis on Harb’s Masail in this masala mentions, “I could not find a biographical for him.” (Masail Harb (2/886 no.1416 footnote 4) END]
His Shaykh in the chain is his uncle Arim, and it is not known whether he narrated from him before or after he became forgetful.
[AK] Arim, who is Muhammad bin Fadhal as-Sadusi is Thiqah Thabt as Hafiz Ibn said in Taqrib ut-Tahdhib (no.6226). he became forgetful and his memory deteriorated. END]
(Athar al-Waridah Fi Jawaz Ghibah al-Hakim al-Ja’ir p.14)
